← All chapters

Ghāyat al-Ḥakīm · draft

Book Three, chapter 6

"Perfect Nature" after Aristotle and Hermes; what a talisman is

Ritter pp. 187–194 · 29 passages

Ritter p. 187

1Chapter 6

فصل (٦)

2And this science, may God strengthen you, can neither be worked nor apprehended except by one in whose natural disposition that lies. And to this Aristotle pointed in the "Book of al-Isṭamākhīs", when he said that the Perfect Nature is a power for the philosopher which increases him in his knowledge and his wisdom. And the sages have differing shares in this spiritual power (rūḥāniyya) — and this is the secret laid down among them, which no one other than they comes to know.

وهذا العلم ايّدك الله لا يتأتّى عمله ولا الوقوف عليه الا لمن فى طباعه ذلك والى هذا اشار «ارسطو» فى «كتاب الاسطماخيس» اذ قال ان الطباع التامّ قوة للفيلسوف تزيده فى علمه وحكمته وللحكماء فى هذه الروحانية — وهذا السرّ الموضوع بينهم الذى لا يطلع عليه احد غيرهم — حظوظ متفاوتة

al-ṭibā' al-tāmm, 'the Perfect Nature', uses ṭibā' (natural disposition), not ṭabī'a; rendered 'Nature' in this fixed expression.

3And it is the secret concealed in wisdom, since there was no chapter of the chapters of wisdom, subtle or great, that the sages did not disclose to their pupils and pass around among themselves by correspondence or by questioning, except this concealed secret, which is the spiritual power of the Perfect Nature.

وهو السرّ المكتوم فى الحكمة اذ لم يكن من ابواب الحكمة باب لطيف ولا جليل ابدته الحكماء لتلاميذهم واداروه فيما بينهم بمكاتبة او سؤال ما خلا هذا السرّ المكتوم الذى هو روحانية الطباع التامّ

4And the sages used to name this spiritual power Tamāghīs Baghdīswād Waghdās Nūfānāghādīs. And these four letters are the names of this spiritual power; they used to name it [by them] when they had need of it, and they are an allusion to the Perfect Nature.

وكانت الحكماء يسمّون هذه الروحانية تماغيس بغديسواد وغداس نوفاناغاديس وهذه الاربعة احرف اسماء هذه الروحانية كانوا يسمّونها عند الحاجة اليها وهى اشارة الى الطباع التامّ

The four names are unvocalised; transliteration is tentative. 'Letters' (aḥruf) here means the four words.

5And Hermes related: "When I wanted to bring out the knowledge of the secret of creation and its manner, I came upon a dark underground passage filled with darkness and winds, and I could see nothing in it because of its darkness, and no lamp would hold out for me in it because of the abundance of its winds. Then there came to me one who came in my sleep in the most beautiful form, and he said to me: Take a light and put it in a glass that will shield it from the winds, and it will give light for you along with this. Then enter the underground passage and dig in its middle, and bring out from it the statue of a talisman that has been made; for when you bring out that statue, the winds of that passage will go away and it will be lit for you.

وذكر «هرمس» انى لما اردت استخراج علم سرّ الخليقة وكيفيتها وقعت على سرب مظلم مملوء ظلمة ورياحًا فلم ابصر فيه شيئًا لظلمته ولم يصبر لى فيه سراج لكثرة رياحه فاتانى آتٍ فى منامى باحسن صورة فقال لى خذ نورًا فضعه فى زجاجة تقيه من الرياح وتنير لك مع هذا ثم ادخل السرب واحفر فى وسطه واستخرج منه تمثال طلسم معمول فانك اذا استخرجت ذلك التمثال ذهبت رياح ذلك السرب واضاء لك

sarab: an underground passage or tunnel. ṣūra here in its general sense, 'form'.

Ritter p. 188

6Then dig in four corners of it, for you will bring out the knowledge of the secrets of creation, the causes of nature, the wonder of things and their qualities. So I said to him: And who are you, O you? And he said to me: I am your perfect nature; if you wish to see me, call me by my name.

ثم احفر فى اربعة اركان منه فانك تستخرج علم سرائر الخليقة وعلل الطبيعة وبديع الاشياء وكيفياتها فقلت له ومن انت يا هذا فقال لى انا طباعك التامّ فان اردت ان ترانى فادعنى باسمى

ṭibā'uka al-tāmm: 'your perfect nature'; the word is ṭibā', not ṭabī'a.

7I said: And what is the name by which I should call you? And he said: Tamāghīs Baghdīswād Waghdās Nūfānāghādīs. So I said to him: And in what state should I call you, and how should I proceed in my calling you? And he said: When the Moon descends at the head of Aries, at whatever time it may be, by night or by day, enter a clean house and place a table in the corner of the house, on its east side, upon something raised from the ground.

قلت وما الاسم الذى ادعوك به فقال تماغيس بغديسواد وغداس نوفاناغاديس فقلت له وفى ايّ حال ادعوك وكيف اصنع فى دعائى اياك فقال اذا نزل القمر برأس الحمل ايّ وقت كان ليلاً او نهارًا فادخل بيتًا نظيفًا وضعْ خوانًا فى زاوية البيت شرقيه على شىء مرتفع من الارض

The names are transliterated as Ritter prints them. khiwān: a low table for food.

8And take four cups, each cup of which holds a raṭl, and fill each one of them with one of these oils, namely oil of almonds, ghee, oil of walnuts and oil of vinegar [sense uncertain]. Then take four cups after the pattern of the first and fill them with wine. Then make a sweetmeat of walnut oil, ghee, honey and sugar, rich and sweet. Then take the eight cups, the sweetmeat that has been made, and a glass bowl.

وخذ اربعة اقداح يسع كل قدح منها رطلاً فاملأ كل واحد منها من دهن من هذه الادهان وهى دهن اللوز والسمن ودهن الجوز ودهن الخلّ ثم خذ اربعة اقداح على مثال الاول فاملأها خمرًا ثم اصنع حلواء من دهن جوز وسمن وعسل وسكر دسمة حلوة ثم خذ الاقداح الثمانية والحلواء المصنوعة وجام زجاج

duhn al-khall, lit. 'oil of vinegar', is obscure.

Ritter p. 189

9First place the bowl in the middle of the table with the sweetmeat upon it, and place the four cups with the drink around it, facing the four directions: you begin with the eastern, then the western, then the southern, then the northern. Then you begin, of the oils, with the oil of almonds for the east, alongside the cup of drink; then the oil of walnuts, western; then the ghee, southern; then the oil of vinegar, northern.

وضعْ اوّلاً الجام وسط الخوان وعليه الحلواء وضع الاقداح الاربعة بالشراب حواليه موازية للاربع جهات تبدأ بالشرقى ثم الغربى ثم القبلى ثم البحرى ثم تبدأ من الادهان بدهن اللوز للشرق بحذاء قدح الشراب ثم دهن الجوز غربى ثم دهن السمن قبلى ثم دهن الخل بحرى

qiblī and baḥrī, lit. 'of the qibla' and 'of the sea', are rendered southern and northern.

10And this arrangement I found in the "Book of al-Isṭamāṭīs". Then take a candle, light it and place it in the middle of the table. Then take two censers filled with charcoal, and fumigate in one of them with al-kīya [substance uncertain] and frankincense, and in the other with prepared aloeswood.

وهذا التقسيم وجدته فى «كتاب الاسطماطيس» ثم خذ شمعة فاسرجها وضعها فى وسط الخوان ثم خذ مجمرتين مملوءتين فحمًا فدخّن فى احداهما بالكية والكندر وفى الاخرى بالعود المطرى

al-kiyya: mastic. al-'ūd al-muṭarrā: aloeswood treated with perfume.

11Then rise, standing facing the east, and say seven times: Tamāghīs Baghdīswād Waghdās Nūfānāghādīs. Then say after that: I call you, O strong, spiritual, exalted spirits, who are the wisdom of the sages, the discernment of the discerning and the knowledge of the learned: answer me, be present with me, bring me near to your governance, guide me aright by your wisdom, strengthen me by your power, make me understand what I do not understand, teach me what I do not know, and make me see what I do not see and ward off from me the afflictions that cling [to me], of ignorance, forgetfulness and hardness, so that you may join me to the ranks of the first sages, in whose hearts wisdom, sagacity, wakefulness, discernment and understanding dwelt; and dwell in my heart and do not leave me." He mentioned this in the «Isṭamāṭīs»: "For if you do that, you will see me."

ثم قم قائمًا قبالة المشرق وقل مرارًا سبعًا تماغيس بغديسواد وغداس نوفاناغاديس ثم قل فى اثر ذلك ادعوكم ايها الارواح القوية الروحانية المتعالية التى هى حكمة الحكماء وفطنة الفطناء وعلم العلماء فاجيبونى واحضرونى وقرّبونى لتدبيركم وسدّدونى بحكمتكم وايّدونى بقوتكم وفهّمونى ما لا افهم وعلّمونى ما لا اعلم وبصّرونى ما لا ابصر وادفعوا عنى الآفات الملتبسة من الجهل والنسيان والقساوة حتى تلحقونى بمراتب الحكماء الاولين الذين سكنت قلوبهم الحكمة والفطنة واليقظة والتمييز والفهم واسكنوا قلبى ولا تفارقونى، ذكر هذا فى «الاسطماطيس» فانك اذا فعلت ذلك رأيتنى،

tadbīr here in the sense 'governance'. Title read al-Isṭamāṭīs as printed. The speaker of "you will see me" is not named.

Ritter p. 190

12He said: And the sages used to keep up that [rite] with their spiritual power (rūḥāniyya) once or twice every year, in reverence for their perfect nature; and what Hermes the sage told them about them moved them to that, and they knew that they eat that only for love and concord; so they would eat that food, and those whom they loved [sense uncertain: with them].

قال وكانت الحكماء يتعاهدون ذلك من روحانيتهم فى كل سنة مرّةً ومرّتين اجلالاً لطباعهم التامّ ودعاهم لذلك ما اخبرهم «هرمس» الحكيم عنهم وعلموا انهم انما يأكلون ذلك للمحبّة والموافقة فكانوا يأكلون ذلك الطعام ومن احبّوا،

ṭibā' tāmm rendered 'perfect nature' (distinct from ṭabī'a). The closing wa-man aḥabbū is elliptical.

13And Aristotle said: To every sage there is a power that comes to him from the spiritual power, strengthening him and inspiring him and opening for him the locks of the gates of wisdom, that power being joined to his high star which governs him; so it grows up with him and nourishes him. And the sages and the kings used to keep up this spiritual power by this invocation and the names, and it would help them in their knowledge and their wisdom and the governance of their affairs and in being granted success toward their right guidance, and would ward off the evil of the plots of the people of evil from their kingdoms; and it was a help to them in the kingdom and in bringing their word together upon obedience.

وقال «ارسطو» ان لكل حكيم قوة تأتيه من الروحانية تقوّيه وتلهمه وتفتح له مغاليق ابواب الحكمة متصلة تلك القوة بنجمه العالى المدبّر له فهى تربّى معه وتغذيه فكان الحكماء والملوك يتعاهدون هذه الروحانية بهذه الدعوة والاسماء فكانت تعينهم على علمهم وحكمتهم وتدبير امرهم والتوفيق لرشدهم وتدفع شرّ مكايد اهل الشرّ من ممالكهم وكانت لهم عونًا على المملكة وجمع كلمتهم على الطاعة

14So this spiritual power — he says to Alexander — O King, which governs you: I have told you its names and uncovered for you the secret hidden in it; and were it not for the King's rank and his worth with me, I would not have uncovered that to him nor told him of them.

فهذه الروحانية — يقول للاسكندر — ايها الملك المدبّرة لك قد اخبرتك باسمائها وكشفت لك عن السرّ المكتوم فيها ولولا منزلة الملك وقدره عندى لما كشفت له ذلك ولم اخبره بها

The address shifts from second to third person ('the King') as printed.

Ritter p. 191

15So keep up this invocation at the first of your setting out, and name the names of this spiritual power, for it will grant you success and make you mighty, and will overcome for you whoever sets himself against you, and will humble what has proved hard for you and subdue it.

فتعاهد فى اول مخرجك هذه الدعوة وسمِّ اسماء هذه الروحانية فانها توفّقك وتعزّك وتغلب لك من ناصبك وتذلّ ما استصعب عليك وتقهره

16When you have done that, do not neglect the matter of the stars, and do not march except by them, for the stars are the head of the governance of the world, and by them the affair of the two worlds, the small and the great, is upheld. So seek the help of the spiritual powers of your star, the four, which are the perfect nature, and in the four names [sense uncertain] of which I informed you, the secret of secrets; and they became four only because the natures are four.

فاذا فعلت ذلك فلا تغفل امر النجوم ولا تسر الا بها فان النجوم رأس تدبير الدنيا وبها قام امر العالَمين الصغير والكبير فاستعن روحانيات نجمك الاربعة التى هى الطباع التامّ وفى الاسماء الاربعة التى انبأتك بها سرّ الاسرار وانما صارت اربعة لكون الطبائع اربعة

wa-fī l-asmā' is awkward. sirr al-asrār may refer to the book of that name (Secret of Secrets). Ritter prints rūḥāniyyāt najmika.

17So invoke by them and keep them up at every one of the times, and take refuge in them in your affair and in what is closed to you; although I have seen for you from your high star that you will overcome Persia and kill its kings, and at the first of your departing from your lands to the lands of Persia you will meet with severe hardship from them.

فادع بها وتعاهدها فى كل وقت من الاوقات وافزع اليها فى امرك وفى ما يغلق عليك مع انى قد رأيت لك من نجمك العالى انك تغلب على فارس وتقتل ملوكها واول ما تنفصل من بلادك الى بلاد فارس تلقى منهم جهدًا شديدًا

18And when the affair exhausts you and you despair of victory, the spiritual power of your perfect nature, which is joined to your star, will rise up at an invocation that comes from you; so take refuge in it when the hardship distresses you. Then it will join with your star, then cast its rays by its power upon the helpers of the king of Persia and his viziers and his commanders, and will draw the affection of their hearts to you, and will suggest to them the killing of their king and hearing and obedience to you. Upon that they will rise in the morning and gather in their council, and their word will be united upon you, and the affection of their hearts will be joined to you, and they will unite upon killing the king and bring you his head, hearing and obedient to you.

فاذا اجهدك الامر ويئست من الظفر قامت روحانية طباعك التامّ المتصلة بنجمك عند دعوة تكون منك وافزع اليها حين يكربك الجهد فتتصل بنجمك ثم تلقى شعاعها بقوتها على اعوان ملك فارس ووزرائه وقوّاده فتجذب مودّة قلوبهم اليك وتومئ اليهم بقتل ملكهم وبالسمع والطاعة لك فيصبحون عند ذلك ويجتمعون فى مجلسهم فتجتمع كلمتهم عليك وتتصل مودّة قلوبهم بك ويجتمعون على قتل الملك ويأتونك برأسه سامعين مطيعين لك

19And I see for you victory and dominion over all the kings, all of them; and they will be afraid of you and seek peace with you. And I see your death in a land of iron and a sky of gold, after your seizing of the lands and your killing of the kings and your levying of riches and treasures. This is what I see of the power of your star and the dominance of your rule and the spiritual power of your perfect nature." This is the text of Aristotle's words on that.

وارى لك غلبةً وقهرًا لجميع الملوك كلهم وتفزع منك وتطلب موادعتك وارى منيّتك فى ارض من حديد وسماء من ذهب بعد نزوعك البلدان وقتلك الملوك وجبايتك الاموال والكنوز فهذا ما ارى من قوة نجمك وغلبة ملكك وروحانية طباعك التامّ، هذا نصّ كلام «ارسطو» فى ذلك،

Ritter p. 192

20And I saw in the «Reports of Persia» something that I thought I should mention to you; namely, that when Alexander set out for the king of Persia, and he was in a number that could not be counted for multitude, the number of Alexander's men was reported to him [the king of Persia], and the king of Persia asked about his conduct and about his circumstances, since he had drawn near to him; and his intimates advised him to send to him someone to meet him. And among the words of the king of Persia was that he said: "I see the upper world turned toward this man and aiding him, and one does not doubt that whoever fights him has fought the upper world, and whoever fights the upper world is necessarily a loser." And this is what «Aristotle» had foretold to Alexander.

ورأيت فى «اخبار فارس» ما رأيت ان اذكره لك وذلك ان الاسكندر لما توجّه لملك فارس وكان فى عدد لا يحصى كثرةً نقل عدد رجال الاسكندر له ‹ف›سأل عن سيرته ملك فارس وعن احواله اذ قرب منه فاشاروا اليه خاصّته ان يبعث اليه من يلقاه فكان من كلام ملك فارس ان قال انى ارى العالم العلوى مقبلًا على هذا الرجل ومعينًا له ولا يشكّ فى ان من حاربه فقد حارب العالم العلوى ومن حارب العالم العلوى فانه خاسر ضرورةً فهو الذى انبأ به «ارسطو» الاسكندر،

li-malik Fāris may also be read li-mulk Fāris, 'for the kingdom of Persia'. 'he was in a number that could not be counted' [pronoun ambiguous: Alexander, i.e. his army, is the likelier referent].

21And it is mentioned in this book that the first sage who devised the talisman — the spiritual power (rūḥāniyya) appeared to him and guided him to the wondrous works, and his perfect nature guided him, and granted him success, and gave him insight into the obscurities of the secrets, and said to him: "I am with you, and I shall not appear to anyone after you except to one who calls me by my name and offers me a sacrifice in my name" — [was] «Karfasāyis». For this man used to see with the eye of his spiritual power and to know with a spiritual heart; and between him and Ādamānūs, who is Adam, there were ten fathers, and of years two thousand two hundred and sixty years.

وذكر فى هذا الكتاب ان اول حكيم استخرج الطلسم وظهرت له الروحانية وارشدته للاعمال العجيبة وهداه طباعه التامّ فوفّقه وبصّره بغوامض الاسرار وقال له انا معك ولن اظهر لاحد بعدك الا لمن يدعونى باسمى ويقرّب لى قربانًا باسمى «كرفسايس» فان هذا الرجل كان ينظر بعين روحانيته ويعرف بقلب روحانى وكان بينه وبين آدمانوس وهو آدم عشرة آباء ومن السنين الفان ومائتان وستون سنة

'this book' is the book named just before in Ritter's text. The syntax leaves unclear whether «Karfasāyis» is the name of the sage (predicate of anna) or the name by which the spirit is to be invoked. al-ṭibā' al-tāmm, 'perfect nature', is a technical term distinct from ṭabī'a.

22And among the words of this sage: "It is not fitting for the sage who works with talismans to occupy his soul, his mind, his discernment and his resolve with any of the works other than that; and that is because of what the maker of the talisman needs of intensity of thought and deliberate study for joining these spiritual spirits one to another. And whoever occupies his soul with any of the branches of wisdom other than that, his resolve and his discernment fall short of it, and he does not exhaust its branches nor the working of it" — and the like, as this sage said.

ومن كلام هذا الحكيم: لا ينبغى للحكيم العامل بالطلسمات ان يشغل نفسه ولبّه وفطنته وهمّته بشىء من الاعمال سوى ذلك وذلك لما يحتاج اليه عامل الطلسم من شدّة الفكر وتعمّد النظر لتأليف هذه الارواح الروحانية بعضها الى بعض ومن شغل نفسه بشىء من ابواب الحكمة سوى ذلك قصرت همّته وفطنته عن ذلك ولم يستقص ابوابها ولا العمل بها ونحو ما قال هذا الحكيم،

himma, 'resolve', is used in what follows as a technical term for the operator's concentrated will. abwāb, lit. 'doors', rendered 'branches'.

Ritter p. 193

23And to this «Ṭumṭum» the Indian alluded, with the use of thought, at the beginning of his book, and he made thought the mainstay of his book. And he also mentioned that the talisman is called a talisman only because it is spiritual powers gathered by resolve, bound fast in that in which they are bound fast. And the spiritual powers are four: al-hammāma diffused in the world; the spiritual power of the instrument by which this spiritual power is drawn; the spiritual power of sound resolve; and the spiritual power of the craftsmanship by hand.

والى هذا اشار «طمطم» الهندى باستعمال الفكرة فى اول كتابه وجعل عمدة كتابه الفكرة، وذكر ايضًا ان الطلسم انما سمّى طلسمًا لانه قوًى روحانية مجموعة بالهمّة مشدودة فيما هى مشدودة فيه، والقوى الروحانية اربع الهمّامة المبثوثة فى العالم وروحانية الآلة التى تجذب بها هذه الروحانية وروحانية الهمّة الصحيحة وروحانية الصنعة باليد،

al-hammāma [sense uncertain]: apparently a term for the active spiritual force diffused through the world (later called 'the spiritual power of motion and rest'); left transliterated. al-ṣan'a here is the manual making, rendered 'craftsmanship' rather than the glossary's 'the craft'.

24And these three spirits, which are the instrument, the resolve and the craftsmanship, are cast upon the diffused al-hammāma, and by them its ray is drawn and its part is bound in that in which it is desired to bind it; like the polished mirror which a man raises in his hand in the light of the Sun and turns with its face toward the shade, and by its brightness he draws the ray of that light, and it casts it into the shade, so that it becomes luminous and shining without anything of that light being diminished. Likewise these three spiritual powers are cast upon the diffused al-hammāma, which is the spiritual power of motion and rest, and draw that. So this, he said, is the meaning of the name 'talisman'.

وهذه الارواح الثلاثة التى هى الآلة والهمّة والصنعة تلقى على الهمّامة المبثوثة فتجذب بها شعاعها وتقيّد جزءها فيما يراد تقييدها فيه كمثل المرآة الجليّة التى يرفعها الرجل بيده فى نور الشمس ويقلب بوجهها الى الظلّ فيجذب بنورها شعاع ذلك النور وتلقيه فى الظلّ فيصير نيّرًا مضيئًا من غير ان ينتقص من ذلك النور شىء كذلك هذه الروحانية الثلاث تلقى على الهمّامة المبثوثة التى هى روحانية الحركة والسكون فتجذب ذلك فهذا قال معنى اسم الطلسم،

25And he said at the beginning of this book: "The first thing with which you begin in your affair, in what concerns your own soul, is that you look to your spiritual power that governs you, whose link is joined to your star; and this is the perfect nature which «Hermes» the sage mentioned in his book, when he said that the small world, which is man, when he is perfect in nature, his soul is like the disc of the Sun fixed in the heaven, which illuminates with its rays every horizon; and likewise the perfect nature: its ray stands in the soul, and its ray penetrates and falls upon the powers of the subtleties of wisdom, and by that ray of its it draws the powers of wisdom until it establishes them in the soul, which is its place, just as the ray of the Sun draws the powers of the world and raises them into the air.

وقال فى اول هذا الكتاب اول ما تبتدئ به من امرك فى خاصّة نفسك ان تنظر الى روحانيتك المدبّرة لك المتصل وصلها بنجمك وهو الطباع التامّ الذى ذكره «هرمس» الحكيم فى كتابه اذ قال ان العالم الصغير الذى هو الانسان اذا كان تامّ الطباع كانت نفسه بمنزلة قرص الشمس الثابت فى السماء المضيء بشعاعه كل افق وكذلك الطباع التامّ يقوم شعاعه فى النفس فينفذ شعاعه فيقع على قوى لطائف الحكمة فيجذب بشعاعه ذلك قوى الحكمة حتى يقيمها فى النفس التى هى مكانه كما يجذب شعاع الشمس قوى العالم فيرفعها فى الجوّ،

al-ṭibā' al-tāmm, 'the perfect nature', as above. al-ṭibā' al-tāmm, 'the perfect nature', is distinct from ṭabī'a (nature) in the glossary; ṭibā' is rendered 'nature' throughout this passage.

Ritter p. 194

26And the sage Socrates said: The perfect nature is called the sun of the sage, and his root and his branch. And Hermes was asked; it was said to him: By what is wisdom attained? And he said: By the perfect nature. And it was said to him: What is the root of wisdom? He said: The perfect nature. And it was said to him: And what is the key of wisdom? He said: The perfect nature.

وقال «سقراطيس» الحكيم الطباع التامّ يقال له شمس الحكيم واصله وفرعه، وسئل «هرمس» فقيل له بم تستدرك الحكمة فقال بالطباع التامّ وقيل له ما اصل الحكمة قال الطباع التامّ وقيل له وما مفتاح الحكمة قال الطباع التامّ

Suqrāṭīs = Socrates. The print shows فال for قال before the last answer, evidently a lost dot.

27And it was said to him: And what is the perfect nature? And he said: The spiritual power (rūḥāniyya) of the philosopher, which is joined to his star and governs him; it opens for him the locks of wisdom, teaches him what was obscure to him, inspires him with what is right, and instructs him in the keys of the gates in sleep and in waking.

فقيل له وما الطباع التامّ فقال روحانية الفيلسوف التى هى متصلة بنجمه ومدبّرة له تفتح له مغاليق الحكمة وتعلمه ما اشكل عليه وتوحى اليه بالصواب وتلقّنه مفاتيح الابواب فى النوم واليقظة،

28So the perfect nature is, for the philosopher, in the position of the sincere teacher who instructs the boy word after word, and whenever he has mastered one chapter of knowledge, he brings him into another chapter; and that boy will not fear deficiency in knowledge as long as that teacher remains with him, because he uncovers for him what was confused to him, teaches him what was obscure, and begins to teach him what he does not ask about. Thus is the perfect nature for the philosopher.

فالطباع التامّ للفيلسوف بمنزلة المعلّم الناصح الذى يلقّن الصبىّ الكلمة بعد الكلمة فكلما احكم بابًا من العلم ادخله فى باب آخر ولن يخاف ذلك الصبىّ النقص فى العلم ما دام له ذلك المعلّم باقيًا لانه يكشف له ما اشتبه عليه ويعلمه ما اشكل ويبتدئه بتعليم ما لا يسأل عنه فهكذا الطباع التامّ للفيلسوف،

29So know that. And it is for that reason that we said that the knowledge and practice of this science are not attainable for a person, nor acquaintance with its secrets, except for one in whose nature that is. And this was the reason for bringing in the words of the sage Aristotle on that; so understand.

فاعلم ذلك ومن اجل ذلك ما قلنا ان هذا العلم لا يتأتى لانسان علمه وعمله ولا الوقوف على اسراره الا لمن فى طباعه ذلك وكان هذا سببًا لاجتلاب كلام الحكيم «ارسطو» فى ذلك فتفهم،

'ilm is rendered 'science' for hādhā l-'ilm and 'knowledge' for 'ilmuhu ('its knowledge').